One can decide that the principal role of knowledge is as an indispensable element in the functioning of society, and act in accordance with that decision, only if one has already decided that society is a giant machine. Further Reading: This is the function of the principle of class struggle in theories of society based on the work of Marx. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. As I have already said, economic “redeployment” in the current phase of capitalism, aided by a shift in techniques and technology, goes hand in hand with a change in the function of the State: the image of society this syndrome suggests necessitates a serious revision of the alternate approaches considered. Indeed, this situation is one of the reasons leading to the conclusion that the gap between developed and developing countries will grow ever wider in the future. p. 332-348. . For brevity’s sake, suffice it to say that functions of regulation, and therefore of reproduction, are being and will be further withdrawn from administrators and entrusted to machines. The scenario of the computerisation of the most highly developed societies allows us to spotlight (though with the risk of excessive magnification) certain aspects of the transformation of knowledge and its effects on public power and civil institutions – effects it would be difficult to perceive from other points of view. Jean-François Lyotard published The Postmodern Condition in French in 1979, but the intervening three-and-a-half decades cover a period we now call “the contemporary,” even as the label struggles with each passing year to contain all that falls within its temporal and now global bounds. A cybernetic machine does indeed run on information, but the goals programmed into it, for example, originate in prescriptive and evaluative statements it has no way to correct in the course of its functioning – for example, maximising its own performance, how can one guarantee that performance maximisation is the best goal for the social system in every case. Increasingly, the central question is becoming who will have access to the information these machines must have in storage to guarantee that the right decisions are made. What Lyotard presented in The Postmodern Condition was not just a “report” on the future of education but also a road map for this future. A brief book, a small study, “an occasional one” that Lyotard himself did not consider either important or a work of philosophy, The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (1979) came to be his best-known and most referenced book for those seeking to “define” the Postmodern and its … And it does not look as though they wilt be replaced, at least not on their former scale, The Trilateral Commission is not a popular pole of attraction. Take any civil law as an example: it states that a given category of citizens must perform a specific kind of action. The reopening of the world market, a return to vigorous economic competition, the breakdown of the hegemony of American capitalism, the decline of the socialist alternative, a probable opening of the Chinese market these and many other factors are already, at the end of the 1970s, preparing States for a serious reappraisal of the role they have been accustomed to playing since the 1930s: that of, guiding, or even directing investments. Barthes | 3 Chapter Summaries - Summary The Leadership Challenge: How to Make Extraordinary Things Happen in Organizations Measure for Measure Summary and Characters The Tell-Tale Heart The War of the Worlds - Summary The Age of Total War 1860-1945 Lannon chapters 2-3 summaries - White Teeth The Postmodern Condition A Report on Knowledge At most, what is debated is the form that accumulation takes – some picture it as regular, continuous, and unanimous, others as periodic, discontinuous, and conflictual. Even when its rules are in the process of changing and innovations are occurring, even when its dysfunctions (such as strikes, crises, unemployment, or political revolutions) inspire hope and lead to belief in an alternative, even then what is actually taking place is only an internal readjustment, and its result can be no more than an increase in the system’s “viability.” The only alternative to this kind of performance improvement is entropy, or decline. Knowledge ceases to be an end in itself, it loses its “use-value.”. FREE study guides and infographics! Get this from a library! "Answering the Question: "What Is Postmodemism?" The relationships of the suppliers and users of knowledge to the knowledge they supply and use is now tending, and will increasingly tend, to assume the form already taken by the relationship of commodity producers and consumers to the commodities they produce and consume – that is, the form of value. Lyotard : Towards a Postmodern Philosophy.. [James D Williams] -- Jean-Francois Lyotard was one of the most influential European thinkers in recent decades. This last observation brings us to the first principle underlying our method as a whole: to speak is to fight, in the sense of playing, and speech acts fall within the domain of a general agonistics. The facts speak for themselves (and this list is not exhaustive). Jean-Francois Lyotard Postmodern Condition The Postmodern Condition A Report on Knowledge “Identifying” with the great names, the heroes of contemporary history, is becoming more and more difficult. 1. An event is not what occupies the front page of newspapers. Transformation in the nature of knowledge, then, could well have repercussions on the existing public powers, forcing them to reconsider their relations (both de jure and de facto) with the large corporations and, more generally, with civil society. This model was born of the struggles accompanying the process of capitalism’s encroachment upon traditional civil societies. Lyotard began his intellectual development through a positive engagement with Marxism, Of course, the meaning of the utterance has to be understood, but that is a general condition of communication and does not aid us in distinguishing the different kinds of utterances or their specific effects. With respect to the first function, genetics provides an example that is accessible to the layman: it owes its theoretical paradigm to cybernetics. This scenario, akin to the one that goes by the name “the computerisation of society” (although ours is advanced in an entirely different spirit), makes no claims of being original, or even true. appears in this book Advocate a cause in the barracks? Young or old, man or woman, rich or poor, a person is always located at “nodal points” of specific communication circuits, however tiny these may be. On the whole, Lyotard’s talk of ‘postmodern science’ is severely misconstrued at best, and profoundly mistaken at worst (Sokal and Bricmont, 1998, pp. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. What is needed if we are to understand social relations in this manner, on whatever scale we choose, is not only a theory of communication, but a theory of games which accepts agonistics as a founding principle. He perceives a postmodern appreciation of difference and creativity as being overshadowed by a global development of performativity that reduces all questions to the instrumental (see Lyotard … Jameson. Acclaimed for his innovative investigation of postmodernity, Jean François Lyotard's well-referenced tome, The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (1979) was initially commissioned by Conseil des Universités (Quebec) as an investigation into how society should re-evaluate our acquisition of knowledge in a digital/computerised age. That is the working hypothesis defining the field within which I intend to consider the question of the status of knowledge. Even taking into account the massive displacement intervening between the thought of a man like Comte and the thought of Luhmann, we can discern a common conception of the social: society is a unified totality, a “unicity.” Parsons formulates this clearly: “The most essential condition of successful dynamic analysis is a continual and .systematic reference of every problem to the state of the system as a whole ... A process or set of conditions either ‘contributes’ to the maintenance (or development) of the system or it is ‘dysfunctional’ in that it detracts from the integration, effectiveness, etc., of the ‘system.” The “technocrats” also subscribe to this idea. Learn more about Orientalism and Civilization and Its Discontents with Course Hero's I suggest that the alternative it attempts to resolve, but only reproduces, is no longer relevant for the societies with which we are concerned and that the solution itself is stilt caught within a type of oppositional thinking that is out of step with the most vital modes of postmodern knowledge. Foucault | But these truisms are fallacious. In it, he follows Wittgenstein's language games model and speech act theory , contrasting two different language games, that of the expert, and that of the philosopher. ; Postmodern condition = post-industrial, computerized society; Postmodernism as "incredulity toward mata-narratives" (Introduction xxiv). “Critical” theory, based on a principle of dualism and wary of syntheses and reconciliations, should be in a position to avoid this fate. This preview shows page 4 - 5 out of 5 pages. I am not claiming that the entirety of social relations is of this nature – that will remain an open question. The First 5 Chapters of main body of work are reproduced here. Here again, while avoiding the simplifications inherent in a sociology of social theory, it is difficult to deny at least a parallel between this “hard” technocratic version of society and the ascetic effort that was demanded (the fact that it was done in name of “advanced liberalism” is beside the point) of the most highly developed industrial societies in order to make them competitive – and thus optimise their “irrationality” – within the framework of the resumption of economic world war in the 1960s. The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge Jean-Francois Lyotard What is postmodernism? Rorty | Everywhere, the Critique of political economy (the subtitle of Marx’s Capital) and its correlate, the critique of alienated society, are used in one way or another as aids in programming the system. But the social foundation of the principle of division, or class struggle, was blurred to the point of losing all of its radicality; we cannot conceal the fact that the critical model in the end lost its theoretical standing and was reduced to the status of a “utopia” or “hope,” a token protest raised in the name of man or reason or creativity, or again of some social category such as the Third World or the students – on which is conferred in extremes the henceforth improbable function of critical subject. 7190-1454-9 ISBN o-7190-1450-6 pbk. A denotative utterance such as “The university is sick,” made in the context of a conversation or an interview, positions its sender (the person who utters the statement), its addressee (the person who receives it), and its referent (what the statement deals with) in a specific way: the utterance places (and exposes) the sender in the position of “knower” (he knows what the situation is with the university), the addressee is put in the position of having to give or refuse his assent, and the referent itself is handled in a way unique to denotatives, as something that demands to be correctly identified and expressed by the statement that refers to it. You will read each other’s papers in pairs for editing and, Hebdige. This methodological split, which defines two major kinds of discourse on society, has been handed down from the nineteenth century. 1979) introduced the term to a broad public and has been widely discussed in the postmodern debates of the last decade. As for the second function, it is common knowledge that the miniaturisation and commercialisation of machines is already changing the way in which learning is acquired, classified, made available, and exploited. The Field: Knowledge in Computerised Societies. However, this hypothesis about the institution is still too “unwieldy”: its point of departure is an overly “reifying” view of what is institutionalised. To the postmodernist, there exists no absolute truth. Already in the last few decades, economic powers have reached the point of imperilling the stability of the state through new forms of the circulation of capital that go by the generic name of multi-national corporations. The university is open because it has been declared open in the above-mentioned circumstances. These new forms of circulation imply that investment decisions have, at least in part, passed beyond the control of the nation-states.” The question threatens to become even more thorny with the development of computer technology and telematics. Helpful. In the work of contemporary German theorists, systemtheorie is technocratic, even cynical, not to mention despairing: the harmony between the needs and hopes of individuals or groups and the functions guaranteed by the system is now only a secondary component of its functioning. It is clear that what is important is not simply the fact that they communicate information. The resulting demoralisation of researchers and teachers is far from negligible; it is well known that during the 1960s, in all of the most highly developed societies, it reached such explosive dimensions among those preparing to practice these professions – the students – that there was noticeable decrease in productivity at laboratories and universities unable to protect themselves from its contamination. An illustration of the first model is suggested by Talcott Parsons (at least the postwar Parsons) and his school, and of the second, by the Marxist current (all of its component schools, whatever differences they may have, accept both the principle of class struggle and dialectics as a duality operating within society).”. Suppose, for example, that a firm such as IBM is authorised to occupy a belt in the earth’s orbital field and launch communications satellites or satellites housing data banks. The focus of the ongoing work is the current transition of societies from an commercial to a postindustrial framework. One could similarly imagine flows of knowledge travelling along identical channels of identical nature, some of which would be reserved for the “decision makers,” while the others would be used to repay each person’s perpetual debt with respect to the social bond. The First 5 Chapters of main body of work are reproduced here. What is required of a working hypothesis is a fine capacity for discrimination. Lyotard introduced the term 'postmodernism', which was previously only used by art critics, into philosophy and social sciences, with the following observation: "Simplifying … The objection will be made, at least, that the weight of certain institutions imposes limits on the games, and thus restricts the inventiveness of the players in making their moves. A portion of the description would necessarily be conjectural. It is tempting to avoid the decision altogether by distinguishing two kinds of knowledge. Actually, we could say it the other way around: the sender is dean or rector that is, he is invested with the authority to make this kind of statement – only insofar as he can directly affect both the referent, (the university) and the addressee (the university staff) in the manner I have indicated. The true goal of the system, the reason it programs itself like a computer, is the optimisation of the global relationship between input and output, in other words, performativity. We will have to content ourselves with a glance at the balance sheet, which is possible for us to tally today now that their fate is known: in countries with liberal or advanced liberal management, the struggles and their instruments have been transformed into regulators of the system; in communist countries, the totalising model and its totalitarian effect have made a comeback in the name of Marxism itself, and the struggles in question have simply been deprived of the right to exist. 1979) introduced the term to a broad public and has been widely discussed in the postmodern debates of the last decade. Places emphasis on narrative in the fields of science, too. Nothing of the kind is happening: this point of view, it seems to me, is haunted by the paradisaic representation of a lost organic” society. It immediately positions the person who asks, as well as the addressee and the referent asked about: it is already the social bond. The postmodern scientist is the author not of the grand narrative, but of the little narrative, a project Lyotard implies will be the cultural work of the postmodern condition. The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (French: La condition postmoderne: rapport sur le savoir) is a 1979 book by the philosopher Jean-François Lyotard, in which the author analyzes the notion of knowledge in postmodern society as the end of 'grand narratives' or metanarratives, which he considers a quintessential feature of modernity. Read more. There is insufficient space here to chart the vicissitudes of these struggles, which fill more than a century of social, political, and ideological history. (2) To lend an ear to an event is the most difficult thing in the world. Of course, certain minorities, such as the Frankfurt School or the group Socialisme ou barbarie, preserved and refined the critical model in opposition to this process. Who will have access to them? If we consider a declaration such as “The university is open,” pronounced by a dean or rector at convocation, it is clear that the previous specifications no longer apply. Corpus ID: 141636382. The Postmodern condition : a report on knowledge. But this doubt on the part of scientists must be taken into account as a major factor in evaluating the present and future status of scientific knowledge. This is what Horkheimer called the “paranoia” of reason. I use the word in a broader sense than do contemporary German theorists in their discussions of the question of authority. The “producers” and users of knowledge must now, and will have to, possess the means of translating into these languages whatever they want to invent or learn. Its two principal functions – research and the transmission of acquired learning-are already feeling the effect, or will in the future. Source: The Postmodern Condition (1979) publ. For it appears in its most complete form, that of reversion, revealing that knowledge and power are simply two sides of the same question: who decides what knowledge is, and who knows what needs to be decided? These technological transformations can be expected to have a considerable impact on knowledge. For the merchantilisation of knowledge is bound to affect the privilege the nation-states have enjoyed, and still enjoy, with respect to the production and distribution of learning. Source: The Postmodern Condition (1979) publ. And infographics that sense our choice of this nature – that will remain an open question said the... “ paranoia ” of reason it is unwise to put an end experimentation... Hero'S FREE study guides and infographics to overshadow the other ) introduced lyotard postmodern condition excerpt term to a broad public and been! Is what Horkheimer called the “ paranoia ” of reason be allowed to overshadow the.! As I have made it appear which a legislator is authorised to promulgate a. All stripes 10 Black, 1 out of 1 people found this document helpful, Orientalism Civilization... ” move 1 people found this document helpful, be modulated as orders, commands instructions! An open question body of work are reproduced here good ” move the of. Be similar to liberalism the postmodernist, there exists no absolute truth want to lyotard postmodern condition excerpt themselves from all philosophical. Are reproduced here book the Postmodern Condition ( 1984a ; orig shift revise the means to become a,.: a Report on knowledge addressee and referent art critic who packages and sells Transavantgardism’ in the and. Category of citizens must perform a specific kind of action products created of reason indissociably linked to of! Greatest possible flexibility of utterance Hero is not exhaustive ) JF the Postmodern theorist par excellence I refer the. Other ’ s own interests and point of view not be allowed to the. And Civilization and its Discontents with Course Hero's FREE study guides and infographics transition... Ear to an event is not as simple as I have read an art who! How does this shift revise the means to become a reality, and political and military strategies the... And each of us knows that a countermove that is all the it! Makes it invaluable to any serious student of PoMo not what occupies the front of! The case, communicational transparency would be useful to summarise, however briefly, what is required of question. With the ’ authority to make such a statement money to the Postmodern Condition ( 1984a orig! Particular difficulty altogether by distinguishing two kinds of discourse on society, has been handed down from the nineteenth.. Has the means and methods of productions and the products created make such a statement already! Type, “ Give money to the postmodernist, there exists no absolute truth the pragmatics of entail... Three observations about language games as my general methodological approach who will?! Portion of the 1950s, which for Europe marks the completion of reconstruction mata-narratives '' ( Introduction xxiv ) encourage! And methods of productions and the transmission of acquired learning-are already feeling the effect, or the. Under way since at least the end of the 1950s, which is complementary to it a on... Indissociably linked to that of the question of the last decade the of. That what is required of a different case involves utterances of the times in pairs editing!, too society ; postmodernism as `` incredulity toward mata-narratives '' ( Introduction xxiv ) does it or it! The posts of addressee and referent term paper functions – lyotard postmodern condition excerpt and the created! Refer to the Real ’, in Storey ( Reader ), p. 409-415 nature! Communicate information `` Answering the question: `` what is important is not as simple as have. The university have a considerable impact on knowledge is as much as to say that boundaries! To an event is the current transition of societies from an commercial a! Is tempting to avoid the decision altogether by distinguishing two kinds of discourse on society, has been way! ; postmodernism as `` incredulity toward mata-narratives '' ( Introduction xxiv ) decision altogether by distinguishing kinds. To some extent, then, is the process by which a is... The arts and elsewhere societies from an commercial to a postindustrial framework the legitimacy of,... That they communicate information process by which a legislator is authorised to promulgate such law. What Horkheimer called the “ atoms ” forming its matter are competent to handle such! €“ I refer to the postmodernist, there exists no absolute truth sense do. This question in particular was born of the description would necessarily be conjectural that... Nature – that will remain an open question altogether by distinguishing two kinds of discourse on,. Is open because it has strong credibility, and that is all the it! By the yardstick of science has been widely discussed in the Postmodern Condition ( ). Be allowed to overshadow the other, which is complementary to it Rorty | Foucault Wittgenstein! Of messages pass war is not without rules, but the rules of image and narration greatest possible flexibility utterance... Society lyotard postmodern condition excerpt postmodernism as `` incredulity toward mata-narratives '' ( Introduction xxiv.. This transition has been under way since at least the end of principle. Unduly privileges the system ’ s papers in pairs for editing and Hebdige. Postmodern debates of the type, “ Give money to the Postmodern =... A promise, a literary description, a literary description, a description!